BUYING GUIDE
Should You Repair or Replace Your Garage Door?
Usually, fix it. Springs, cables and openers wear out years before a decent door does, and none of them mean the door is done. Here's how to tell when it really is.
Should you repair or replace your garage door?
Repair it if the door itself is solid and one part has failed. Replace it when the repair would cost more than half of a new door, or when the door is rusting through, rotting or warped. We do both for homes across Salt Lake City and the valley. A broken spring, a snapped cable or a dead opener doesn’t mean the door is finished. Those parts wear out years before a decent door does.
Repair or replace at a glance
- Typical repair: $100–$860
- New door, installed: about $1,150–$1,870
- Rule of thumb: once a repair passes half the price of a new door, price the new door too
- How long a door lasts: 15–30 years if it’s looked after
- How long an opener lasts: 10–15 years
Typical 2026 prices, not a quote. We’ll price it both ways for you, free.
What does each one cost?
| Typical price | |
|---|---|
| Broken spring | $300–$540 |
| Frayed or snapped cable | $170–$320 |
| Opener repair | $150–$700 |
| One damaged panel | $400–$900 |
| Two or three damaged panels | about $1,720–$2,580 |
| New one-car door, installed | about $1,090–$1,670 |
| New two-car door, installed | about $2,190–$3,350 |
New-door prices swing a lot with what you pick. A plain uninsulated door can be $400 to $700, and a custom one can run past $3,500. So before you compare, decide what you’d replace it with.
When is a repair the right call?
When what broke is a part and the door is fine.
The spring snapped, and the door was working the day before. That’s a repair. A cable frayed. Repair. The opener quit, but when you pull the release cord the door lifts easily by hand. The door is fine, and it’s the opener that needs attention.
One dented panel on a door that’s only a few years old is usually a repair too, as long as the maker still sells that section. And a door that’s noisy and jerky often needs nothing more than a tune-up, which runs $120 to $240.
A door that’s looked after lasts 15 to 30 years. If yours is ten years old with a broken spring, it has a lot of life left.
When is it time for a new garage door?
When the door itself is giving out. Look at the bottom section first. That’s where road salt and snowmelt drip off the car all winter, and it’s where steel doors rust through and wood doors go soft. Then check the sections for cracks or bowing, and look at whether the door still seals against the weather when it’s shut. A bent or rusted track or frame counts too.
A repair doesn’t cure any of those. They come back.
The other test is your own receipts. If you’ve paid for several repairs in the last few years and another is due, add them up. Once the next one would cost more than half of a new door, stop and price the door.
How does the half-price rule work with real numbers?
Take a damaged panel. One section runs $400 to $900. On a two-car door, where a new one is about $2,190 to $3,350, that’s clearly under half, so replace the section. On a one-car door it can land on either side of half, so get both prices.
With two or three sections damaged you’re at about $1,720 to $2,580. A new one-car door is about $1,090 to $1,670. You’d be paying new-door money to keep an old door.
Springs never trip the rule. At $300 to $540, a new spring buys a healthy door years more use.
What about the opener?
Treat it as a separate question. The opener is its own machine with a shorter life, about 10 to 15 years. A dead opener is no reason to buy a door, and a new door doesn’t always need a new opener.
It can work the other way, though. If you’re getting a new door and the opener is already past ten, doing both in one visit saves you a second trip. Prices are in the opener replacement cost guide.
Is an insulated door worth it in a Salt Lake City winter?
If the garage is attached to the house, yes. A bare steel door does nothing to hold back the cold. An insulated one is rated anywhere from R-6 to R-18, and you’ll notice it most if there’s a bedroom over the garage or you work out there in January.
For a detached garage that only holds the car, save your money and buy the plain door. And if you like the door you have and only want it warmer, an insulation retrofit costs less than replacing it.
If the door is solid, fix what broke and keep it. If it’s past that, here’s what goes into a new door installation. Not sure which side you’re on? Tell us what’s going on and we’ll price it both ways, free.
Repair or replace FAQs
Is it cheaper to repair or replace a garage door?
Repair, in nearly every case. Most repairs cost $100 to $860, and a new door costs about $1,150 to $1,870 installed. Replacing makes sense when the repair would cost more than half of a new door, or when the door itself is failing.
How long does a garage door last?
A garage door that's looked after lasts 15 to 30 years. Steel and aluminum doors tend to outlast wood. Springs and openers wear out sooner, and you can replace them without replacing the door.
Should I replace the door if only the spring broke?
No. A broken spring is a $300 to $540 repair and says nothing about the door. The same goes for cables and most opener problems.
Can I replace one garage door panel instead of the whole door?
Often, yes. One section runs $400 to $900. With two or three sections damaged, you're at about $1,720 to $2,580, which is more than a new one-car door costs.
How much does a new garage door cost in 2026?
About $1,150 to $1,870 installed, with $1,400 typical. A one-car door runs about $1,090 to $1,670 and a two-car door about $2,190 to $3,350.
Do I need a new opener if I get a new door?
Not always. An opener lasts about 10 to 15 years. If yours is newer and strong enough for the new door, it can stay.
Not sure which way to go?
We'll look at the door and price it both ways, repair and replacement, so you can decide with real numbers. The estimate is free, and nobody's going to push you toward the bigger job.